Skip to Content

Sherwin Williams Creamy vs Alabaster

Looking for the perfect creamy, warm white paint color? Let’s compare Sherwin Williams Creamy vs Alabaster to see which might be perfect for your home!

Cream paint colors are the epitome of elegance, bringing a timeless and refined charm to any space.

Whether you’re looking to create a serene oasis or add a touch of warmth to your home, cream paints offer a versatile palette that can be easily tailored to your desired aesthetic.

I love a good cream paint color because it is light and bright without feeling cold or sterile at all!

Two of the most popular colors in this category are Sherwin Williams Creamy and Alabaster.

Read my full review of Creamy

Read my full review of Alabaster

Creamy vs Alabaster

Creamy and Alabaster and two super popular cream paint colors. In fact, at a glance they might look the same.

But, when you put them next to each other you will clearly see the difference in color and undertone!

SW creamy vs Alabaster

What is similar about Creamy vs Alabaster?

Creamy and Alabaster are both warm toned off white or cream paint colors.

They are both technically considered off white, but can appear to be closer to white, especially in a very bright room.

These are two super popular paint colors and both can be great for giving your room that light, bright, and airy look without feeling cold or icy at all.

What is different about Creamy vs Alabaster?

RBGR: 239 G: 232 B: 219R:237 G:234 B:224
Undertoneswarm, beige tonedwarm, beige toned, gray


LRV measures the darkness of a color, with 100 being pure white. With LRVs of 81 and 82, these two colors are very similar in darkness, but Alabaster is slightly lighter and brighter compared to Creamy.


These are both warm toned colors with beige undertones. However, when you put the colors next to each other, you will clearly see that Alabaster has a lot more gray to it compared to Creamy.

How do I decide between these two colors?

Take a good look at the lighting in your room. Do you have bright, south facing light? This warm light will make Creamy look a bit yellow. Alabaster, with it’s gray tones, will feel a little more neutral.

On the other hand, if you have north facing windows or cool, LED lighting in the room, Alabaster could start to read as a light gray. So, Creamy might be a better option!

It’s very important to swatch colors on your wall to be sure they look good – day and night – in your actual space before committing.

Click here to get removable peel & stick paint samples to easily swatch with!

Before you go…

Still not sure which cream paint color is right for you? Let’s look at all of your options by exploring the best cream paint colors for your home!

Still not sure what paint color to choose?

paint color formula square mockup

My Paint Color Formula ebook walks you through the painless process of expertly testing paint swatches to ensure you have the perfect color for your home.

Learn more about the Paint Color Formula here!

The best way to sample paint? Samplize!

Get peel-and-stick removable and reusable paint samples here!

Paint color Planner mock up

Thanks for reading!

the paint color formula ad click here

Sharing is caring!