Sherwin Williams Westhighland White vs Alabaster: Let's Compare!

Looking for the perfect white paint color for your home? We've compared Westhighland White vs Alabaster to find what suits you best!

You probably already know why white walls are popular – they provide a clean, neutral backdrop that works with any decor style.

But let’s face it, bright whites can feel a bit stark. That’s where creamy whites and off-whites come in, offering a cozy vibe while still keeping things nice and clean.

So, in this post, we're comparing two super popular shades of white paint – Westhighland White and Alabaster.

Read my full review of Westhighland White

Read my full review of Alabaster

Westhighland White vs Alabaster

Both Westhighland White and Alabaster are beloved warm whites, but they each have their own unique flair.

What is similar about Westhighland White vs Alabaster?

Westhighland White and Alabaster are both creamy whites with close Light Reflectance Values (LRVs).

Both colors are light, bright, and perfect for almost any room in your house. They also make fantastic trim colors, and even can be used as a whole-house paint color.

What is different about Westhighland White vs Alabaster?

Westhighland White (LRV 86) is the lighter, brighter sibling of Alabaster (LRV 82). It’s considered a true white, while Alabaster flirts with the line between off-white and true white.

Westhighland White boasts creamy and greige undertones, giving it a bright, neutral appeal.

Alabaster, with its warm beige undertones, brings a touch more warmth to the table.

	Westhighland White	Alabaster
LRV	86	82
RGB	R: 243 G: 238 B: 227	R: 237 G: 234 B: 224
Undertones	creamy and greige undertones	warm, beige undertones

Light Reflectance Value (LRV)

LRV measures how much light a color bounces around on a scale from 0 (pure black) to 100 (pure white).

Westhighland White (LRV 86) is a bit lighter, brighter and whiter than Alabaster (LRV 82).

Westhighland White fits into the true white category (LRVs 83-100).

Meanwhile, Alabaster sits right on the edge, making it an off-white (LRVs 72-82) that sometimes masquerades as a true white.

But don’t worry; both shades have a creamy depth that keeps them from being too stark.

Undertones

Westhighland White has creamy and greige undertones, making it a touch cooler.

Alabaster’s warm, beige undertones give it a cozy warmth. This means Alabaster is a bit warmer than Westhighland White.

Both Westhighland White and Alabaster may look warmer and creamier in south-facing rooms with lots of natural light.

Both colors could look a bit darker and cooler in north-facing rooms without much natural light.

How do I decide between these two colors?

Both Westhighland White and Alabaster are stellar choices.

If you’re after a true white or something slightly cooler, go with Westhighland White.

If you prefer a creamy white with a hint of warmth, Alabaster is your go-to.

So, which shade speaks to you? Whether you’re Team Westhighland White or Team Alabaster, you can’t go wrong with these timeless whites.

Thanks for reading!