Skip to Content

Sherwin Williams Extra White vs Alabaster: let’s compare

Looking for the perfect off white paint color? Let’s compare Sherwin Williams Extra White vs Alabaster to see which might be perfect for your home!

White paint colors are a super popular choice for many homeowners.

And, it’s a great choice. White walls are a fresh backdrop, neutral and appealing, and work with a ton of different color schemes and decor styles.

When it comes to white paint colors, off-white is usually a bit easy to decorate with compared with a stark white.

It’s just softer, easier on the eyes, and feels more cozy and inviting.

Two of the most popular colors in this category are Sherwin Williams Extra White and Alabaster.

Read my full review of Extra White

Read my full review of Alabaster

Sherwin Williams Extra White vs Alabaster

Extra White and Alabaster are both super popular off white paint colors by Sherwin Williams. But, they have very different tones and looks to them.

Let’s dive in to explore their similarities and differences!

SW Extra White vs Alabaster

What is similar about Extra White vs Alabaster?

Extra White and Alabaster are similar in that they are both off-white paint colors. Both are popular options that will help your room to feel light, bright, and inviting.

However, they have some pretty significant differences!

What is different about Extra White vs Alabaster?

These are both off-white paint colors, but they are very different both in brightness and tone.

Extra WhiteAlabaster
RBGR:238 G:239 B:234R:237 G:234 B:224
Undertonesslightly cool with light blue/gray undertoneswarm, beige toned undertones

Click here to get a peel & stick sample of Extra White!

Click here to get a peel & stick sample of Alabaster!


Light Reflective Value is the measurement of how much light a color bounces around. This is on a scale of 0 to 100 with 0 being pure black and 100 being pure white.

Extra White has and LRV of 86, which is a decent amount lighter than Alabaster at 82.

Because of this, plus the undertone differences, Extra White feels a lot brighter and fresher compared to Alabaster.


These two shades of off white have very different undertones. Extra White, while fairly neutral, definitely has cool, crisp undertones.

On the other hand, Alabaster is firmly warm in it’s undertones. So, it will feel cozier and warmer than the crisp Extra White.

Remember to take into account the lighting in your space.

South facing windows let in warm toned light, which will make the wall color feel more yellow. So, in a south facing room, extra white will feel neutral and alabaster will feel very warm.

On the other hand, north facing windows let in cool blue light that will make colors feel cooler. So, Extra White could feel quite cool, maybe even a touch blue, while Alabaster will look more neutral.

It’s very important to swatch colors on your wall to be sure they look good – day and night – in your actual space before committing.

Click here to get removable peel & stick paint samples to easily swatch with!

How do I decide between these two colors?

While these are both off white paint colors, they have totally different feels to them. You need to decide what feel you are going for!

If you want a crisp, clean white, Extra White is the perfect option.

If you want a soft white wall that will feel warm, cozy, and not too stark, then Alabaster is a better option.

Sherwin Williams Extra White color palette

Join the (free!) PaintColorProject+ community to access this exclusive color palette! Once you join, you can right click & save the palette image!

Sherwin Williams Extra White paint color palette

Still not sure what paint color to choose?

My Paint Color Formula ebook walks you through the painless process of expertly testing paint swatches to ensure you have the perfect color for your home.

Learn more about the Paint Color Formula here!

The best way to sample paint? Samplize!

Get peel-and-stick removable and reusable paint samples here!

Paint color Planner mock up

Thanks for reading!

about me paint color project picture
the paint color formula ad click here

Sharing is caring!