Skip to Content

Sherwin Williams Eider White vs Agreeable Gray: Let’s compare!

Looking for a neutral paint color? Let’s compare Sherwin Williams Eider White vs Agreeable Gray to see if one is right for your home.

People love neutral paint colors. It’s understandable why – they are universally pleasing and work with many home styles and color schemes.

Two of the most popular neutral paint colors are Eider White and Agreeable Gray.

Read my full review of Eider White

Read my full review of Agreeable Gray

Eider White vs Agreeable Gray

eider white vs agreeable gray

What is similar about Eider White vs Agreeable Gray?

These are both neutral greige colors. Beyond that, they are truly completely different!

What is different about Eider White vs Agreeable Gray?

One major difference is the LRV – light reflective value – of these colors. Agreeable Gray is SIGNIFICANTLY darker compared to eider white. If you have a brightly lit room, Eider White can look so washed out – like a true white. Agreeable Gray has much more color to it.

Eider WhiteAgreeable Gray
RBGR:226 G:222 B:216R:209 G:203 B:193
UndertonesLight gray color with warm undertones, often reads pink or even purpleWarm toned shade of gray with pink/yellow/tan undertones


Agreeable Gray does not have one specific strong undertone. It really bounces/reflects the colors around it. Reddish tones will make it look more pink, golden tones make it look more yellow.

Eider White has warm undertones. In certain lights, it can read purple or even pink! These undertones are less visible in bright, natural light. If your room is dark, prepare to see more pink.

How do I decide between these two colors?

If you want a light, bright, room, Eider White is best. However, swatch it really well to check to see if it reads pink – especially at night. Eider White is really a very light gray.

If you want more of a neutral, beige color – Agreeable Gray is for you.

Read my complete Agreeable Gray color review here!

Agreeable Gray comparisons

Deciding between Agreeable Gray & other colors?

Does Agreeable Gray look beige?!

Click here to get a peel & stick sample of Agreeable Gray!

Agreeable Gray paint color palette

Join the (free!) PaintColorProject+ community to access this exclusive color palette! Once you join, you can right click & save the palette image!

agreeable gray color palette

Still not sure what paint color to choose?

paint color formula square mockup

My Paint Color Formula ebook walks you through the painless process of expertly testing paint swatches to ensure you have the perfect color for your home.

Learn more about the Paint Color Formula here!

The best way to sample paint? Samplize!

Get peel-and-stick removable and reusable paint samples here!

Paint color Planner mock up

Thanks for reading!

the paint color formula ad click here

Sharing is caring!