Looking for the perfect warm gray paint color? Let's compare Sherwin Williams City Loft vs Agreeable Gray to see which might be perfect for your home!
There are so many options when picking a paint color for your home, it can be super overwhelming.
Even if you narrow the color down, there are tons of shades within each color family.
Warm grays (AKA greiges) are a super popular wall color because they are neutral, cozy, and easy to decorate with.
Two of the most popular colors in this category are Sherwin Williams City Loft and Agreeable Gray.
Read my full review of City Loft
Read my full review of Agreeable Gray
Sherwin Williams City Loft vs Agreeable Gray
City Loft and Agreeable Gray are both light, warm, gray paint colors. At a glance, they look pretty darn similar. But, get them next to each other and you will see some of the differences!
What is similar about Sherwin Williams City Loft vs Agreeable Gray?
These colors are both on the mid to light end, but darker than an off-white. They are solidly in the "light gray" category.
They also both have warm undertones, meaning they will feel cozy and maybe a touch golden.
But, what makes up their undertones is totally difference!
Click here to get a peel & stick sample of Agreeable Gray!
Click here to get a peel & stick sample of City Loft!
What is different about Sherwin Williams City Loft vs Agreeable Gray?
| City Loft | Agreeable Gray | |
| LRV | 70 | 60 |
| RBG | R: 223 G: 218 B: 209 | R:209 G:203 B:193 |
| Undertones | warm toned with beige and red undertones | warm toned shade of gray with slight green |
Light Reflectance Value
Light Reflective Value is the measurement of how much light a color bounces around. This is on a scale of 0 to 100 with 0 being pure black and 100 being pure white.
With an LRV of 70, City Loft is considerably lighter than Agreeable Gray, with an LRV of 60.
This means that City Loft will feel much lighter in brighter. If your room is very light - or you are even picking colors for an exterior - the colors will be more washed out.
In a super bright space, City Loft can almost feel off white, while Agreeable Gray is always going to have a bit more depth to it.
Undertones
While these colors are both warm toned, they have different undertones that get them there. Looking at the colors side by side makes this pretty clear.
City Loft has a bit more beige and red to it - it can almost read as a touch pink.
On the other hand, Agreeable Gray is more neutral, the warmth is more subtle. It can occasionally read as a touch green.
How do I decide between these two colors?
First, decide if you want a very light gray or something with a bit more depth to it. City Loft is significantly lighter compared to Agreeable Gray.
Then, look at the undertones. You will want to make sure that the either pink or green undertones don't clash with any wood tones or other fixtures in your space.
It's very important to swatch colors on your wall to make sure they look good – day and night – in your actual space before committing.
Click here to get removable peel & stick paint samples to easily swatch with!
Overall, City Loft is just a lighter and brighter paint color compared to Agreeable Gray, which can feel a bit deep, especially in a darker room!
Sherwin Williams City Loft color palette
Want to use this paint color in your home? Instantly upgrade your home's aesthetic with our exclusive paint color palette. Unlock the perfect trim color and six stunning accent colors, a combination of neutrals and bold hues for an instantly harmonious space!
Get your perfect paint color palette by clicking here!
Agreeable Gray Paint Color Palette
Want to use this paint color in your home? Instantly upgrade your home's aesthetic with our exclusive paint color palette. Unlock the perfect trim color and six stunning accent colors, a combination of neutrals and bold hues for an instantly harmonious space!
Get your perfect paint color palette by clicking here!
Still unsure which paint color is right for your space?
Choosing paint doesn’t have to be stressful! My free Paint Color Planning Quick Start Guide walks you through the exact steps to confidently choose the perfect color — without the overwhelm, second-guessing, or endless swatch testing.
👉 Click here to download the free guide!
My Paint Color Formula course walks you through the painless process of expertly testing paint swatches to ensure you have the perfect color for your home.
The best way to sample paint? Samplize!
Get peel-and-stick removable and reusable paint samples here!
Thanks for reading!
Morgan is passionate about home decor and paint colors. She has been sharing DIY home decor tips since 2012 at CharlestonCrafted.com. From there, she learned to love paint colors, and the Paint Color Project was born in 2022!
